top of page

Substantial Transformation: The Worst Rule for Determining Origin of Goods – Except for All the Rest


By: John M. Peterson


Determining the origin of an imported product for purposes of assessing Customs duties has gained exceptional importance in recent years due to the imposition of “retaliatory” duties on Chinese goods pursuant to Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 and “national security” duties on steel and aluminum imports pursuant to Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962. Although United States courts, eight decades ago, pronounced a rule of “substantial transformation” based on manufacturing or processing that results in the creation of a new article of commerce, having a name, character, or use different than its ingredients or

materials, United States Customs and Border Protection has strayed from that rule, providing it lip service, but making origin determinations on such amorphous and subjective bases such as defining the “essential” component of a good or requiring “sufficient” working or processing. This Article discusses why the traditional “substantial transformation” rule best serves the needs of international commerce.

6 Comments


George
George
Jan 29

"Delve into the paradox of the Domestic Violence Charges New Jersey 'Substantial Transformation' rule—a nuanced exploration divorce lawyers in nassau county new york of its challenges and merits in determining the origin of goods. Unraveling complexities, this insightful piece navigates through the rule's limitations and its crucial role in trade regulations."

Like

Gerard Butler
Gerard Butler
Jan 29

ProFormance Global has worked with clubs, coaches and 1000's of players in supporting their individual journey in football. The focus at ProFormance is always on the individual Proformance Football  and helping each person become the best possible version of themselves. Based in Hertfordshire, England with relationships across the globe.


Like

silversteakhospital472
Dec 19, 2023

The healthcare Orthopedic Surgeon In New Gurgaon is continually evolving to meet the growing demands of the community. Modern hospitals and medical facilities in the area provide state-of-the-art equipment and amenities, facilitating a conducive environment for orthopedic surgeries and rehabilitation.

Like

downloadpcgames25
Dec 18, 2023

Adrenaline-Pumping Action: The game's fast-paced action and intense combat sequences provide an adrenaline rush. This can serve as a form of stress relief or escapism for players, Army of Two game for pc allowing them to immerse themselves in a thrilling virtual world.


Like

silverstreakhospital4
Dec 16, 2023

Beyond clinical treatments, gynaecologists contribute significantly to women's holistic wellbeing. They provide essential education on sexual health, menopause, and Gynaecologist In New Gurgaon overall wellness, empowering women to make informed decisions about their bodies and health. This educational aspect fosters a sense of empowerment and autonomy.


Like
bottom of page