top of page

Criminal Justice is Local: Why States Disregard Universal Jurisdiction for Human Rights Abuses

By: Jeremy A. Rabkin and Craig S. Lerner

A German court recently convicted a minor Syrian official of abuses committed in Syria’s civil war. The case was announced with fanfare but has since stirred no interest. Nor should this be surprising. The world has been here before. There was intense excitement in 1998, when British authorities arrested Augusto Pinochet, the former president of Chile, for human rights abuses committed in Chile. It was taken at the time as vindicating the doctrine that the worst human rights abuses fall under “universal jurisdiction,” allowing any state to prosecute, even for crimes against foreign nationals on foreign territory. As generally acknowledged today, this “watershed” produced barely a trickle of consequences. Notably, no former head of state has been prosecuted by another state under this rubric. Commentators have remarked upon the disappointing results but not offered much to account for them. This Article is the first to address this puzzle by situating “universal jurisdiction,” as a technical doctrine, in the context of its broader impulse, sometimes called “transnational justice”––or previously, “cosmopolitan justice.” The underlying claim is that otherwise rivalrous nation-states can and should affirm a broader commonality in prosecuting offenses universally acknowledged to be crimes against humanity. Although the idea has inspired human rights activists, it has failed to engage prosecutors. In analyzing the resulting pattern, this Article makes two central claims. First, the recurring failures of transnational justice cannot be explained by the project’s novelty. Centuries ago, the most prominent Enlightenment thinkers endorsed a version of cosmopolitan justice. It was later advocated as a doctrine that might justify interstate prosecutions within the United States. Such doctrines have never been embraced, however, by courts or even by prosecutors.

3 Kommentare

raja perumal
raja perumal
21. Okt. 2022

Solar energy is the technology used to harness the sun's energy and make it useable. As of 2011, the technology produced less than one tenth of one percent of global energy demand.Many are familiar solar systems Sydney with so-called photovoltaic cells, or solar panels, found on things like spacecraft, rooftops, and handheld calculators.

Gefällt mir

14. Okt. 2022

Basically, business organization envelops all features of the organization engaged with request to guarantee a business works business administration really and effectively. This includes directing and overseeing the tasks of a business, taking choices and the proficient association of hierarchical assets to accomplish authoritative objectives and goals.

Gefällt mir

13. Sept. 2022

We can change over, download, and play in many organizations. It has worked on the HD media player and furthermore saves to play on any cell phone. Besides, this product is an Enemy of Infection Assurance since it safeguards our PC via programmed filtering downloads for infections and Utorrent Crack Download malware. It gives simple and early admittance to clients. The clients gain admittance to updates and state of the art highlights. The clients and allies of uTorrent help amusement and happiness through a promotion free encounter.

Gefällt mir
bottom of page